MyHeritage vs. Ancestry for tracing a deceased relative

Both platforms will assemble a family around a death record within an afternoon. Both charge real money. The difference is in which records each one holds, how the matching works, and whether the person you are chasing is American by lineage or global by accident. Geography decides early. That last point settles most debates on its own.

The record bases

Ancestry’s strength is the United States. The census collection is the reference standard — every US census with personal data, indexed and searchable. Around it sit the state vital records, military files, newspapers, probate papers, and city directories that make American genealogical research possible in an afternoon.

MyHeritage’s strength is everywhere else. Its records are strongest for Europe, and its global reach covers places Ancestry indexes thinly. For a US-born relative with three generations in Ohio, Ancestry has the better paper trail. For a family that crossed an ocean in 1905, MyHeritage is frequently the only platform with the relevant records.

Death records specifically

For the narrow question of a death date, the Social Security Death Index on FamilySearch is free and wins outright — this comparison only matters once that index runs out, which happens for deaths reported after the public index stopped growing, and for people who died without a reported Social Security record.

Past that point, Ancestry’s burial records and newspapers carry the US depth, and MyHeritage’s own burial index is a genuinely underrated resource — a separate database of grave listings, not a repackaging of Find a Grave.

One caution that applies to both: platform algorithms are eager to match, and both will suggest a “new ancestor” on evidence that a careful human would call thin. A hint is a lead. The document behind it is the fact.

The tools

MyHeritage ships more analytical tools with the subscription: photo restoration and colorization, a record-matching engine that runs overnight and emails you the hits, and a strong DNA integration with ethnicity estimates that are popular with new researchers.

Ancestry counters with the largest DNA database in the industry — meaningful if the goal is identifying distant relatives through shared DNA rather than through paper. Its record hints are generally better because its index is deeper, and its trees are more likely to contain the American branches you care about.

The pricing

Neither is cheap. Both offer free search tiers — you can see that a record exists — and gate the documents behind a subscription. Both run frequent discounts at the annual level, and both are best purchased as a single subscription for the period you actually need rather than as an open-ended monthly.

For one focused search, the honest advice is to check the free index layer first, then buy whichever platform demonstrably holds the records you need. Both platforms let you verify a record exists before you pay; use that.

The verdict for the common cases

The relative is American, three generations back or newer. Ancestry, for the census and vital records.

The family has immigrant roots that matter. MyHeritage, for the European records, with Ancestry as a second pass on the American side.

You have a DNA test in hand and want relative discovery. Ancestry’s DNA database is larger; MyHeritage’s matching tools are friendlier to a newcomer.

You just want a death date and an obituary. Neither. FamilySearch for the index, Legacy.com for the obituary, and the county for the certificate. The comparison page lays out why the free layer so often settles the question alone.

Where to go next

FCRA notice. CNTA is not a consumer reporting agency. The services and records described on this page must not be used for employment, tenant screening, credit, or insurance decisions. See our disclaimer for the full notice.